Scottish Ministers - Weaponising Social Media
We have received a reply to our complaint under Ministerial Code re Lorna Slater.
— For Women Scotland (@ForWomenScot) May 10, 2022
The salient points were not addressed.#ShameOnSlaterhttps://t.co/dudHPg2aew #ForWomenScotland
I've complained twice to Nicola Sturgeon about Scottish Ministers breaching the ministerial code.
The first involved Humza Yousaf who was live tweeting partisan comments about fellow MSPs during the Holyrood Inquiry into the Alex Salmond affair.
The second involved Christina McKelvie who made a false statement on social media while the Scottish Government was involved in an official consultation exercise media - "TWAW - it's the law".
By any objective standard my complaints should have been upheld, but both were rejected on the bogus grounds that the Scottish Government is not responsible for what ministers say via their personal social media accounts.
Now this is nonsense, of course, because if a minister said, for example, that 'Stonewall are the equivalent of a glorified protection racket' - they would be sacked immediately because this would upset Nicola Sturgeon, as well as the SNP hierarchy.
The underlying problem is that the First Minister is both judge and jury when it comes to complaints about the ministerial code - there is no independent oversight so things get swept under the carpet.
Details of the complaints I made in respect of Humza Yousaf and Christina McKelvie to follow.
SNP - Weapon of Choice (July 20, 2022)
SNP Ministers - Abusing Social Media (July 16, 2022)
Scottish Ministers, Sham Consultations and Social Media (July 04, 2022)
Sham Consultation By Scottish Ministers (March 04, 2022)
Scottish Ministers - Misrepresenting the Law ()
On 15 February 2021 Scotland's Minister for Equalities, Christina McKelvie, made the following bold claim on her personal Twitter account:
"Sorry but TWAW is actually the law so no false equivalence at all."
But not only was this claim false and highly misleading - it came at a time when Scottish Ministers were consulting about possible reforms to the Gender Recognition Act.
So how could the Minister for Equalities possibly have been acting in good faith, if she was prepared to tweet such an ill-informed, fallacious view which was widely read and shared on social media?
To my mind this is powerful evidence of a Scottish Minister operating with a closed mind rather than an open one and of the Scottish Government acting in bad rather than good faith?