Scottish Labour - Everyday Sexism



Richard Leonard's leadership of the Scottish Labour Party got off to a shaky start and  The Times reports that he has done himself no favours by lifting the suspension of Alex Rowley MSP who was accused of sexual harassment.

I have to say I agree with the comments of Rowley's accuser who is reported as saying:

“As far as I’m concerned it doesn’t send a good message about how seriously Labour takes harassment claims. It leaves the door wide open.

“Am I surprised? No, I’m disappointed. It’s jobs for the boys. Kezia Dugdale had more disciplinary action levied against her for going into the jungle for charity.

“I’ve never met her but she’s been treated exceedingly shabbily compared to the allegations against him.”


If you ask me, everyday sexism is still alive and well in the Scottish Labour party which doesn't bode well for Richard Leonard's leadership. 

  

https://www.thetimes.co.uk/edition/scotland/labour-rebellion-as-rowley-returns-to-party-lncv2ncc9

Labour rebellion as Rowley returns to party
By Hamish Macdonell - The Times

Richard Leonard, with Jeremy Corbyn, has angered Scottish Labour’s MSPs by bringing back Alex Rowley - JEFF J MITCHELL/GETTY IMAGES

Richard Leonard is facing the first internal rebellion to his leadership of Scottish Labour over his decision to bring Alex Rowley back into the fold.

Mr Leonard, who took over as leader last month, lifted a suspension on Mr Rowley, MSP for Mid Scotland Fife, despite an incomplete investigation into allegations of stalking and harassment. The decision has angered some Labour MSPs.

One insider said: “The MSPs are furious over the way this has been handled.”

Some are incensed that Mr Leonard accepted Mr Rowley’s resignation as deputy leader, allowed him to return to the parliamentary party and then installed Lesley Laird, a left-wing ally of Mr Leonard and Mr Rowley, in his place. “This seems to be a classic stitch-up,” the insider said.

Mr Leonard is understood to be preparing to announce the make-up of his shadow cabinet today.

Another Labour source said: “If he brings Rowley back into the shadow cabinet as well, there will be uproar. Then it will really seem like jobs for the boys.”

One Labour MSP pointed out that Kezia Dugdale, the former party leader, was issued with a written warning and had to go through a rigorous process when she returned last week from her unauthorised absence on the reality TV show I’m a Celebrity . . . Get Me Out of Here. “There has been nothing like that for Alex, he was just readmitted to the party and he hasn’t been cleared,” the MSP said.

“The investigation into his behaviour has been abandoned but he hasn’t been cleared. He also disappeared for weeks on an unauthorised absence and he hasn’t been hauled up in front of the leadership.”

Mr Rowley was suspended from the Scottish parliamentary Labour party in last month after allegations surfaced that he had sent abusive text messages to a former partner. Mr Rowley strongly denied the allegations.

He was then absent from parliament for three weeks, suffering from what colleagues described as a stress-related illness.

It is understood that the woman involved decided not to offer her full co-operation to the party investigation, and because the inquiry team could not get hold of all the information it needed the investigation into Mr Rowley’s behaviour was halted.

In a statement, Mr Rowley, who led the party after Ms Dugdale resigned, said: “I am pleased the panel has discharged the case which I referred to them, but I am disappointed that they were unable fully to investigate — and I to have the opportunity to answer — the allegations, which relate to the acrimonious end to a relationship nearly five years ago.”

Mr Leonard said: “He is a loyal and experienced member of the Labour group in the Scottish parliament and will continue to play a part in rebuilding the Labour Party in Scotland.”

However, the woman Mr Rowley is accused of harassing hit back at the Labour party for the way that it had treated her and her complaints.

The woman, who did not want to be named, told The Sun on Sunday: “As far as I’m concerned it doesn’t send a good message about how seriously Labour takes harassment claims. It leaves the door wide open.

“Am I surprised? No, I’m disappointed. It’s jobs for the boys. Kezia Dugdale had more disciplinary action levied against her for going into the jungle for charity.

“I’ve never met her but she’s been treated exceedingly shabbily compared to the allegations against him.”


Lead By Example (18/12/17)


The Sunday Times reported that Alex Rowley has had his suspension from the Labour group at Holyrood lifted, but fails to explain why an investigation into his alleged conduct could not proceed.

Just because the complainant wished to remain anonymous seems a poor excuse if you ask me, because complaints are often made anonymously by people who fear retribution and victimisation for speaking out, sometimes with very good reason.

So this seems far from good or best practice which is worrying because such a high profile public organisation as the Scottish Labour Party out to be leading by example.

  

https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/rowley-ive-no-chance-to-answer-allegations-rprbkdzf2?shareToken=e32e9ad98319651940e1e3811a42a722

Rowley: I’ve no chance to answer allegations

By John Boothman - The Sunday Times
A woman has accused Rowley of a three-year campaign of harassment -PA

Alex Rowley has stepped down as deputy leader of the Scottish Labour party following claims of harassment made against him.

The MSP for Mid Scotland and Fife is expected to have his suspension from the Labour group at Holyrood lifted this week.

Rowley said yesterday that he was disappointed a Labour party panel considering his case had been unable to fully investigate the claims and that he did not have the chance to answer them.

A woman, who wishes to remain anonymous, recently said she had been the victim of three years of harassment. She claimed that he had sent her abusive texts after an acrimonious break-up about five years ago.

At the time Rowley said he “totally” rejected the accusations.

In a statement yesterday Rowley said: “I am pleased the panel has discharged the case which I referred to them, but I am disappointed that they were unable fully to investigate — and I to have the opportunity to answer — the allegations, which relate to the acrimonious end to a relationship nearly five years ago.

“This means the only opportunity to do so would have been through the media and I am not prepared to cause that distress to my family.”

Rowley said he would continue to work as a Labour MSP, his deputy leader role being taken over in the interim by Lesley Laird, MP for Kirkcaldy and Cowdenbeath.

Scottish Labour leader Richard Leonard said Rowley had informed him that he had decided “some time ago” to stand down as deputy and praised him as “a loyal and experienced member of the Labour group who would “continue to play a part in rebuilding the Labour party in Scotland”.

Leonard is expected to reshuffle his opposition front-bench team

this week. Neil Findlay and Monica Lennon are expected to be given key roles, and attention will be paid to the fate of Jackie Baillie and former leader Iain Gray, who backed Leonard’s leadership opponent Anas Sarwar.

Former leader Kezia Dugdale is not expected to feature in the new-look Labour team after her appearance in the TV reality show I’m a Celebrity…Get Me Out Of Here.

Scottish Labour - Everyday Sexism (14/12/17)



No one emerges from the Scottish Labour party 'I'm a Celebrity' debacle with any credit, if you ask me.

MPs are not celebrities and even if they are, or think they are, they're not entitled to go swanning off doing their own thing with no regard to their day job.

Yet Kezia Dugdale did exactly that and incurred the wrath of the Labour hierarchy even though she's not the first Labour politician to behave in this way.

As I've pointed out on the blog site many times, Gordon Brown absented himself from the House of Commons on a frequent, regular basis for five years after the Fife MP stood down as Labour leader in 2010.

Yet no one in the Scottish Labour establishment criticised Gordon Brown for drawing his MP's salary while acting as a visiting 'global leader in residence' at the AbuDhabi campus of New York University.

Read the BBC's report of Scottish Labour's decision to discipline Kezia Dugdale and ponder for a moment the deafening silence surrounding the far more egregious behaviour of Gordon Brown.

Scottish Labour: 'Tough on everyday sexism, tough on the causes of everyday sexism'   

  

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-scotland-politics-42342209

Labour reprimands Kezia Dugdale over I'm a Celebrity


Image copyright - GETTY IMAGES Image caption - Ms Dugdale made no comment to journalists when she returned to the Scottish Parliament on Wednesday afternoon

Scottish Labour has given its former leader a written warning over her controversial appearance on I'm A Celebrity... Get Me Out Of Here!.

But the party said Kezia Dugdale would face no further disciplinary action after her stint on the reality TV show.

Ms Dugdale flew into Glasgow Airport from Australia just before midday.

She then met party bosses, including her successor Richard Leonard, and was formally reprimanded over her "unauthorised absence".

Ms Dugdale later arrived at Holyrood in time for a vote at 17:00, and made no comment to waiting journalists when she left the chamber a short time later.

A statement subsequently released by Scottish Labour said Ms Dugdale had been interviewed by its parliamentary group executive.

Image copyright - REX FEATURES Image caption - Ms Dugdale insisted she had used her time in the jungle to promote Labour values

The statement added: "Following a discussion between Richard Leonard, Kezia Dugdale, and the group executive, it has been decided that the group will reprimand Ms Dugdale by way of written warning. She will not face further action."

It quoted Ms Dugdale as saying that she had "deep regret" that her appearance on the reality show had "caused issues in the first weeks of Richard Leonard's leadership", and that she was now "getting back to work".
Appearance fee

Ms Dugdale, who faced criticism over her three-week absence from the Scottish Parliament while appearing on the show, had earlier said it was "good to be back" in Scotland as she arrived at the airport,

The MSP was the second contestant to be voted off the ITV show, which was won by Made in Chelsea star Georgia Toffolo.

She spent a week in Australia after being evicted from the jungle - and has pledged to donate a percentage of her appearance fee to charity, but has not said exactly how much.
Image copyright - GETTY IMAGES Image caption - She took her seat in the Holyrood chamber in time for a vote at the end of the day's business

Voting statistics released by the programme showed that Ms Dugdale won just 1.67% of the votes on the day she was evicted.

As she arrived in Glasgow, Ms Dugdale said the experience was one she was never going to forget.

The politician, who remained in Australia until after the programme's final on Sunday, had said she wanted to use her appearance to reach out to young people about political values.

Asked if she felt she had in fact promoted Labour values she replied: "I did so in the jungle and will continue to do so."

Image caption - Ms Dugdale arrived back in Glasgow earlier on Wednesday after three weeks in Australia

Ms Dugdale, who was not suspended despite fierce criticism from some within Scottish Labour, has acknowledged she has "a bit of work to do to make amends".

She previously told the BBC's Victoria Derbyshire programme it was difficult to seek approval for her appearance on the show during the leadership contest between Richard Leonard and Anas Sarwar.

The election, triggered by her resignation in August, was won by Mr Leonard - who immediately expressed his disappointment at Ms Dugdale's decision, which was made public just hours before the leadership result was announced.

Mr Leonard said at the time that the party would consider suspending Ms Dugdale - but UK Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn said he did not believe suspension would be appropriate.

After being voted out on the jungle, Ms Dugdale said: "I do understand that it's controversial, I do understand there are lots of people at home that are unhappy that I've taken part in this programme and I've got a bit of work to do to make amends.

"But please don't doubt the fact that I'm devoted to the Labour Party, I love my job and I think I'm better-placed to do it for a long time now having had this experience."

Labour Bullies (21/11/17)



I see that Kezia Dugdale's partner (Jenny Gilruth) has accused Labour of 'bullying' over the threat to discipline its former Scottish party leader for daring to appear on the TV programme 'I'm a Celebrity Get Me Out of Here'.

Now as I said the other day, thesis quite ridiculous especially as the party turned a blind eye to Gordon Brown doing his own thing after stepped down as Labour leader after losing the genera election in 2010.

In Gordon's case, 'doing his own thing' meant accepting a lucrative contract at the Abu Dhabi campus of New York University for 70 days a year which presumably did not include his travelling time. 

As I recall, there was not a murmur of protest from 'leftist' MPs such as Jeremy Corbyn or Dennis Skinner at the time, yet Kezia Dugdale's decision to take a month or so away from her day job at the Scottish Parliament is met with howls of angry criticism.

  

http://www.heraldscotland.com/news/15671479.Kezia_Dugdale_s_partner_accuses_the_Labour_Party_of__bullying_/


Kezia Dugdale's partner Jenny Gilruth accuses the Labour Party of 'bullying'
Kezia Dugdale's partner accuses the Labour Party of 'bullying'

KEZIA Dugdale's partner has accused the Labour Party of bullying the ex-leader over her decision to take part in 'I'm a Celebrity... Get Me Out of Here!'

MSP Jenny Gilruth defended her girlfriend's stance amid threats to suspend Ms Dugdale from the party.

Last night she tweeted: "I see Scottish Labour have developed their own unique take on the final day of #Antibullyingweek. Huge props, comrades! #TeamKez.


Scottish Labour - Everyday Sexism (19/11/17)


Twitter was quick to highlight the threat from Labour’s new Scottish leader, Richard Leonard, to consider suspending his predecessor Kezia Dugdale over her decision to appear on the 'I’m A Celebrity Get Me Out of Here' programme.

Now I've never agreed with MPs or MSPs just swanning off for weeks on end doing exactly what they please, but if you ask me the Kezia Dugdale row smacks of sexism and doubt standards.

Because no one in the Labour Party took Gordon Brown to task when he took up a 70-day a year job as a visiting lecturer to the Abu Dhabi campus of New York University, after Gordon stood down as party leader.

So Richard Leonard's first act as leader seems likely to entrench the ugly, petty factionalism which has bedevilled Scottish Labour for years.

  

Where's Gordo? (27/09/17)


"Where's Gordon Brown?" I asked myself the other day because the part-time Labour MP for Kirkcaldy and Cowdenbeath seemed not be to at the Labour Party conference in Manchester after intervening in the independence referendum to promise Scotland 'home rule', federalism and more powers than you could shake a shitty stick at.  

At first I though Gordo might have flown to Abu Dhabi where he is reportedly contracted to spend 70 days a year at the Abu Dhabi campus of the New York University where he has a second job as a 'distinguished global leader in residence' (DGLIR). 

Now when I first heard Gordon's grand title, DGLIR, I thought that he must be have some personal image problems because why you you call yourself that or allow anyone else to give you such a ridiculous title?

Anyway that's another matter for another day, because soon afterwards I read a report that Gordon was at the United Nations in New York where he has a third job as a special envoy on educational matters, which also uses up a lot of his time in far flung places and foreign travel.

We are only eight months away from the next general election and the big question is will Gordon resign his Kirkcaldy and Cowdenbeath to concentrate on the non-parliamentary interests which take up so much of his time?

I don't know to be honest because he doesn't confide in me, but if he were to ask my advice I would tell him to step down and let someone else pick up the baton because MPs at Westminster are supposed to be full-time, not part-time representatives, of course.

 And if his name was Nadine Dorries rather than Gordon Brown the Labour Party at Westminster would be kicking up a great fuss.

Rampant Sexism (9 June 2014)


I doubt I would vote ever for Tory MP Nadine Dorries, but nonetheless I deplore the fact that she appears to be getting singled out for 'special treatment' - as a result of her high profile absence from the House of Commons.

According to the following report from the BBC, Nadine Dorries faces an inquiry from the Standards Commissioner following her participation in the television programme - I'm A Celebrity....Get Me Out of Here'.

Now the reasons for this inquiry have not been published, but I can't imagine the row is over the payment of a fee - because MPs of all parties in the House of Commons regularly receive fees for doing extra-parliamentary work - huge amounts of money in certain cases.

So the only grounds for complaint that I can see is not that an MP is being paid a fee - but that the MP is being paid their normal salary when they are clearly not in a position to carry out their normal duties - in other words they are getting to eat their cake while being allowed to take an extra slice home in a 'doggy bag'.

In which case there are other 'offenders' and far worse 'offenders' in the Westminster Parliament than Nadine Dorries - and it does seem rather odd, to say the least, that a bolshy woman MP is the only one to face a formal House of Commons inquiry. 

Nadine Dorries faces 'I'm A Celebrity fee' inquiry

Ms Dorries has said that when she receives a fee she will declare it according to Commons rules Continue reading the main story

Tory MP Nadine Dorries is facing a inquiry from the parliamentary commissioner for standards.

The probe is understood to concern her fee for her autumn appearance on ITV's I'm a Celebrity... Get Me Out of Here.

A spokesman for commissioner Kathryn Hudson said she had decided to pursue a complaint received earlier this week.

Ms Dorries, who recently suggested she had not yet received an appearance fee and would obey Commons rules if she did, said she was being "hounded".

The Conservative MP has yet to declare any fee from the reality TV show in the Commons register of members' interests.

In a recent appearance on the BBC's Sunday Politics programme, Ms Dorries said she had not "personally" benefited from going into the jungle.

She said she had a company and added: "When I benefit personally from that I will have to declare it to the register."

Companies House records show she became a director of a limited company called Averbrook in October last year, shortly before going onto the show.

In response to the complaint, Ms Dorries told BBC political correspondent Ross Hawkins: "I'm a backbencher not a minister. My personal finances are my business and nobody else's and if I choose to take money from the company then I will declare it immediately to the standards commissioner."

Later, she took to Twitter to add: "If I haven't declared anything, it's because I haven't earnt anything. I must be the most hounded MP in parliament.

"Journalists, when the standards commissioner concludes the investigation and says there was no case to answer, will you give it prominent coverage?"

The Conservative Party suspended Ms Dorries following her TV appearance, but reinstated her last month.

Suspending Belief (28 November 2012)


I received a very helpful reply to my recent letter to IPSA (Independent Parliamentary Standards Authority) about the payment of MPs' salaries and expenses - while they're off swanning about in the Australian jungle somewhere.

See post dated 22 November 2012 - 'Money For Old Rope'.

The answer is that IPSA is only the administering body when it comes to the MPs' payroll - any decision or instruction to cease payments to an individual 'honourable' member - must come direct from the House of Commons.

In other words MPs just make up the rules to suit themselves - and MPs like 'Mad Nad' Dorries continue to be paid even while suspended - unless the House of Commons instructs otherwise.

Which I imagine would take a vote on the floor of the House of Commons - or a decision from the Speaker of the House that a member should be suspended without pay.

What puzzles me is how an MP can be suspended with pay - if they are clearly unable to do their job?

And in the case of Nadine Dorries that particular point was clearly unarguable - though we may now hear more now that the MP for Mid-Bedfordshire is back in the country.

I heard a Labour MP on the TV the other day gleefully sticking the boot into Nadine Dorries and the Conservative Party - over the 'I'm a Celebrity Get Me Out of Here' debacle.

At one level I have no problem with heaping derision on this particular MP - but what I would like to know from the Peoples' Party is:

'How can Labour make fun of Nadine Dorries and the Tory Party while they turn a blind eye to Gordon Brown's absence abroad for 70 days a year - at the Abu Dhabi Campus of the New York University?'

Now that really is the politics of the madhouse - if you ask me. 

Rampant Sexism (12 November 2012)

Image result for Lion rampant

The Conservative MP for Mid-Befordshire - Nadine Dorries - swans off from the House of Commons for up to 30 days to take part in a celebrity TV programme - which is made in some remote part of Australia.

Result - she gets 'pelters' from all quarters and deservedly so - including from the Deputy Labour Leader - Harriet Harman - while standing in at Prime Minister's Questions (PMQs).

Ms Harman famous for her support of equalities issues even made a lame joke at Nadine's expense - something about the Tory MP having to deal with all kinds of snakes and toads - before she even arrived in the jungle.
So why is the row in the House of Commons so sexist?

Because lots of other MPs swan off when it suits them - including Harriet's Labour colleague and former Prime Minister - Gordon Brown.

Except Gordon is away from his day job for much more time than Nadine Dorries - 70 days a year (every year) in one job alone - at the New York University in Abu Dhabi, for example.

Yet no one says a word - or makes jokes at Prime Minister's Questions.

Maybe they'll start doing so now.

I certainly hope so because it would be a breath of fresh air - and thoroughly deserved.
 

Popular posts from this blog

Kentucky Fried Seagull

Can Anyone Be A Woman?