The BBC showed live footage the other day of hostages being rescued from the so-called Islamic State (IS) by a joint force of American and Kurdish forces, one of whom died in saving these prisoners from certain death.
Intervention in these brutal rogue states is never easy because there are always unintended consequences and a thousand things can always go wrong, as the family of the American soldier, Joshua L. Wheeler, who died knows better than anyone else.
But in the face of so many innocent people being tortured, raped, sold into slavery and murdered in cold blood the big question is whether diplomatic efforts on their own are capable of overturning what is essentially a fascist ideology disguised in religious clothes.
Tortured and beaten: Rescued hostages reveal horrors of life in Islamic State captivity
By Michael R. Gordon - The Age (Australia)
A hostage is searched during the dramatic raid in Huwija. Photo: AP
Salahaddin: Muhammad Hassan Abdullah al-Jibouri had little hope that he would ever make it out of the Islamic State's jail alive, and he had not even seen the sun in more than a month. Then, early last Thursday morning, he heard the helicopters overhead.
The 35-year-old police officer heard bursts of gunfire, and shouts in Kurdish and in English. Suddenly, the door to his cell was battered open.
"Who is there? Who is there?" a soldier yelled, first in Kurdish and then in Arabic.
A line of panicked men flee a prison in Huwija in footage purportedly from the hostage raid. Photo: video via Kurdish regional government
Al-Jibouri was one of 69 Arab prisoners of the Islamic State freed in a military raid near the northern Iraqi town of Huwija last week, the first in which US Special Operations forces were confirmed to have accompanied their Kurdish counterparts onto the battlefield.
On Tuesday, in their first interviews since being brought to the Kurdish autonomous region by US Chinook helicopters, four of the former prisoners described life under the thumb of the Islamic State.
As members of the police, or suspected of ties to the Iraqi government or the United States, the men were beaten and tortured by militants during their captivity. It was all suddenly reversed by a military mission than happened upon them by mistake - the raid had originally been meant to free captured peshmerga fighters.
Told by his Islamic State guards he was just hours away from execution, Saad Khalif Ali Faraj, a 32-year-old police officer, said he had spent his last night in captivity writing a letter to a nephew, urging him not to risk his safety by going searching for him.
After the militants arrived last year, they went house to house, seizing weapons and money, recalled Muhammad Abd Ahmed, 35, who said he was on a leave from the Iraqi army when the Islamic State swooped in. Disarmed and impoverished, Sunni men in the town were later offered $50 if they joined the militants.
The men described an array of exacting restrictions imposed by the militants. Local residents were told down to tiny details what to wear - the cuffs of men's trousers had to be rolled up over the ankle, for instance - and precisely how to position their hands and fingers when praying. Disobedience or carelessness in following the rules provoked suspicion, or even beatings.
Trying to leave the Islamic State's "area of control" was another offence that could lead to severe punishment, said Ahmed Mahmud Mustafa Mohammad, 31.
The militants were wary of anybody who had served in the Iraqi police or army, or whom they thought might have had contact with Americans or Kurds.
The fighters also had a growing need for a detainment network to house those who had come under suspicion. The freed men recalled that the militants referred to the Huwija compound they were kept in simply as "Prison No. 8."
They said that new prisoners were subject to a methodical program of abuse - electrically shocked, beaten with hoses, smothered with plastic bags until they lost consciousness - even without any interrogation questions. Food was meager: pieces of bread pushed through cell doors.
Prisoners were kept in their cells day and night, and the rooms were jammed: al-Jibouri's cell held 39 detainees, he said. And the Islamic State's messaging was relentless. There was a television set in the cell that was used to play Islamic State videos of beheadings, and the captives were forced to watch.
Muhammad had worked as a contractor for a U.S. government aid program in Diyala. But he says that he came under suspicion because of a feud over money with another Huwija resident who tried to get even by denouncing him to a cousin who had joined the Islamic State.
The initial round of beatings he endured soon after being jailed did not appear to be aimed at extracting information. "This was like a process," Muhammad said.
Ahmed said that he was tortured so relentlessly and thought his situation was so hopeless that he decided to end the abuse by signing a confession with his fingerprint even though this would all but seal his death.
Faraj said he came under suspicion because one of his two wives was Kurdish. His brother had already aroused the attention of the militants and been beheaded. "They gave me his head, not his body," he recalled.
Accused of supplying information to the peshmerga, he was jailed by the Islamic State, which also insisted that he divorce his Kurdish wife and mother of five of his children. He refused.
When the Kurdish and U.S. soldiers burst into the prison compound, al-Jibouri said that he felt that his prayers had been answered. "We were very lucky," he said.
He and his fellow prisoners were flown to the city of Irbil, where they met on Tuesday with Massoud Barzani, the president of the Kurdish autonomous region.
Six Islamic State militants who had also been jailed for various offences and who were also taken out of Huwija by the US and Kurdish soldiers received a different sort of welcome: After they were identified by the fellow prisoners, they were led away by the Kurds for questioning.
As the interview came to an end, al-Jibouri asked if he could send a message to an American audience: He said he was grateful to the United States and to Master Sgt. Joshua L. Wheeler, the Army Delta Force member who was killed in the rescue. "May God keep him in heaven," he said.
But the freedom al-Jibouri now enjoys is shrouded with sadness that his family remains in Huwija, which is firmly in the grip of the Islamic State, which is also known by the Arabic pejorative Daesh.
"My wife and my son, I can't see them. I can't see them no more," he said in broken English, erupting into tears. "Our big hope, our wish: just Daesh outside from Iraq."